PRIME Agents are the top 1% of RealEstateAgents.com. They constantly give the greatest service and get the best outcomes for RealEstateAgent.com clients.

WisconsinNew BerlinKaeley Simek
Kaeley Simek profile picture
6 reviews

Kaeley Simek

Completed Profile
Keller Williams Realty Milwaukee Southwest
Prime Agent Badge
PRIME AGENT
7 years of experience
25 sales in last 12 months
120 transactions all-time

Achievements

Trophy Icon
Top Sales Producer 2024
Trophy Icon
Top Negotiator 2024
Trophy Icon
Sells Homes Fast 2024

Business Highlights

Free consultations

Free consultations

Offers customized solutions

Offers customized solutions

7 years in business

7 years in business

Custom home marketing

Custom home marketing

Satisfaction guaranteed

Satisfaction guaranteed

Client Satisfaction & Trust – I’m dedicated to giving you the best real estate experience possible. Integrity and honesty are non-negotiable for me—you’ll always be treated with kindness, transparency, and your best interests at heart.
Strategic Marketing for Maximum Value – My unique approach gets sellers 2-3x more showings (per ShowingTime stats), leading to faster sales and top-dollar offers
Top Notch Communication- Nearly every single client review highlights my clear, proactive, and responsive communication. You’ll always know where we are in the process, what’s next, and even after closing, I’m here for you!
Experienced with a Teacher’s Heart – With 6.5+ years of full-time experience in Southern Wisconsin real estate, I guide you through every step so you feel confident and informed. Ask me anything—your peace of mind is my priority!

About Kaeley

About
Real estate has been part of my life for as long as I can remember. Growing up in the industry alongside my parents, I knew I had to give it a try—and I never looked back! After graduating from Carroll University with a degree in Marketing and a minor in Psychology, I jumped into real estate full-time and have been helping buyers and sellers navigate the market for 6.5+ years. I take pride in providing top-notch communication, expert negotiation, personalized service, and strategic marketing to help my clients achieve their goals. Whether you’re selling for top dollar or finding the perfect home at the best price, I’m here to guide you every step of the way! Outside of real estate, I love traveling, paddle boarding, and spending time with my fiancé, Shawn, and our dog, Sadie. Ready to make your next move? Let’s connect!
Hobbies
Animals, Family, Fitness & Exercise, Health & Wellness, Nature, Outdoor Activities, Technology, Travel, Volunteering, Writing
Education
Bachelor's Degree, Carroll University
Marketing, 2014 - 2018

Professional Information

Brokerage

Keller Williams Realty Milwaukee Southwest

2665 South Moorland Road

New Berlin, WI 53151

Real Estate License
86708 - 94 (Wisconsin), Salesperson
Designations
REALTOR®
Languages
English

Specialties & Awards

Overview

Honored to help buyers and sellers achieve top-notch results with a smooth experience and expert guidance every step of the way!

Specialties

Military (relocation)
VA loans
Relocation
First Time Buyers
Seller Representative
Buyer Representative
Condominiums
Single-Family Homes
New Homes
New Construction

Awards

Top 10 Agents In Volume Sold, KW Gold Award, Million Dollar Producer, Viral Video Award (4 million Views)

Kaeley Simek's Reviews (6)

All
All
Seller
Buyer
Default
Default
Newest First
Oldest First
Highest Rated First
Lowest Rated First
Highly likely to recommend
5.0
Review Date
06/03/2024
Customer
Sarah S. bought a home in Sturtevant

Kaeley made our home buying experience so wonderful! Even with it currently being a sellers market she was able to make me feel protected as a buyer. Anytime a listing came up that met the specifications I asked for she immediately sent them for me to review. She knew how to read my reactions to different houses & knew what questions to ask if I wasn’t sure. It was nothing but a positive experience with her all the way around! I couldn’t have asked for a better realtor!

Highly likely to recommend
5.0
Review Date
08/26/2024
Customer
Daphne F. bought a home in Mukwonago

Could not recommend this woman more highly! We came from out of state and she was able to accommodate visiting multiple properties and doing FaceTimes for walk throughs for us. When we ran into a few hiccups on our prior home sale, she was able to swoop in and help find resolutions very quickly. Her patience and positivity was extremely reassuring when we were losing hope. She worked so well with us, our lenders, title companies, and was very communicative with our realtor in our other state. She was a rockstar given the time frame for our move and the difficulty of getting everything done and ready for us to arrive here and have a place to stay. Thank you so much, Kaeley. We will definitely recommend her for anyone buying/selling in WI!

Highly likely to recommend
5.0
Review Date
03/30/2025
Customer
Adam M. bought a home in Grafton

Kaeley was super helpful every step of the way. From signing up with her to final closing she was always there for any questions or concerns we had. She works her magic with the offers made and helped in many other ways to help get an accepted offer. Highly recommend!

Highly likely to recommend
5.0
Review Date
03/30/2025
Customer
S. D. bought a home in Bay View

We are so lucky to have had Kaeley’s support throughout our first home buying journey. She has a wealth of knowledge, is responsive and answered all and any questions we had throughout the process. Her calm demeanor eliminated any worries we had which we greatly appreciated! Consider yourself lucky if you get the chance to work alongside Kaeley in your home buying journey!

Highly likely to recommend
5.0
Review Date
09/02/2025
Customer
Andreas C S. bought a home in Greenfield

This home finding/bidding/inspecting/closing experience on our new home in Greenfield Wisconsin has been nothing but incredibly amazing. First of all, Kaeley is an extremely, down to earth individual who was always readily available to answer all our questions and address our concerns. It was a pleasure working with her while looking for the perfect home for our family. While still living in SE Indiana during the time we were searching for that home, she made it easy by directing us to suitable online listings that allowed us to narrow the criteria of that perfect home to fit our needs. Once we had a number of potential homes identified, I made the 5 1/2 hour drive to Wisconsin to look at a number of those home. After 4 or 5 days of looking at homes we found the one that suited our needs best. We put in an offer on a Saturday evening and within 24 hours we got the call from Kaeley that the sellers accepted our offer. The rest is history. Thank you so much Kaeley.

Usually responds in 30 minutes
Open 9:00 AM - 8:00 PM