City hero
WisconsinColgate

Find and Compare the Best Real Estate Agents in Colgate, WI

Tell us about your home buying or selling needs and instantly see a personalized list of agents to choose from.

Takes less than 2 mins
100% free service
No strings attached

Featured Agents in Colgate, WI

Prime Agent Badge
PRIME AGENT
Jeff Lien profile picture
First Weber Realtors

Jeff Lien

Completed Profile
View Profile
36years of experience
104sales in the last 12 months
3,000transactions all-time
Prime Agent Badge
PRIME AGENT
Judy Huebner profile picture
Keller Williams Prestige

Judy Huebner

Completed Profile
181 reviews
View Profile
16years of experience
169sales in the last 12 months
969transactions all-time
Mia Scaffidi profile picture
Re/max Xpress

Mia Scaffidi

5 reviews
View Profile
16years of experience
48sales in the last 12 months
400transactions all-time

Compare 15 top-performing real estate agents in Colgate, WI

Shorewest, Realtors

Kevin Nash KNash Team

Completed Profile
9 reviews
Open 8:00 AM - 8:00 PM
Usually responds in 1 hr
27 years of experience
58 sales in last 12 months
925 transactions all-time
Serves Colgate

About

I have selling real estate where I live since 1998. I have been fortunate and blessed to have sold just about 250 million dollars of residential real estate since I began. My focus is to provide you with information that is sound and reliable so that the decision you make is sound decision based on most current and relevant market information available. Currently I head a team of 4 full time agents covering a large demographic area of Metro Milwaukee. We are experts in our field and would be happy to speak with anytime.

Read more

Achievements

Trophy Icon
Top Volume Producer 2025
Trophy Icon
Top Germantown Brokerage 2025
Trophy Icon
Top Listing Agent 2025

Top Producer

Associate's Degree, Oakton College
Business Administration, 1985 - 1987

ABR, CRS, SRES, Licensed real estate agent

Business Highlights

Buyer Representative, Condominiums, Farm/Ranch, First Time Buyers
We love our church, our community and our Harley Davidson
https://discoverhometown.com/realtor-kevin-nash-reflects-on-25-years-serving-germantown-milwaukee-area/

The Stefaniak Group, Llc

Ryan & Peter Stefaniak

Completed Profile
43 reviews
Open 7:00 AM - 7:00 PM
Usually responds in 30 minutes
Prime Agent Badge
PRIME AGENT
48 years of experience
22 sales in last 12 months
2,063 transactions all-time
Serves Colgate

About

Greetings! I am second generation Realtor. Our family has been in the real estate business since 1952. I have been Selling homes since 1977. I have SOLD over 2000 properties in my 50 year career. Thus averaging 50 homes Sold per year. The average agent sells ~5 homes per year. I sell a home every 8 days! I am still full time Agent, enthusiastic, experienced and have track record second to none. If you're interested in working with any experienced, knowledgable Realtor, please contact me as you will not be disappointed. I have the tools to preform and the desire to serve! Past President of Milwaukee Board of Realtors. 1996 Realtor of the Year. Please call ...I love to talk Real Estate.

Read more

Achievements

Trophy Icon
Top Milwaukee Agent 2025
Trophy Icon
Top Company Agent 2025
Trophy Icon
Top Sales Producer 2025

Past President of Greater Milwaukee Assn Of Realtors. Past Recipient, "Realtor of the Year Award"

Associate's Degree
1976

GRI

Business Highlights

1031 Tax Exchange, Condominiums, Distressed Properties, Farm/Ranch
Marathon Runner. Have completed 35 Marathons including Boston 4 times.

Keller Williams Realty

Sara Dreyer

Completed Profile
8 reviews
Open 24 hours
Usually responds in 1 hr
31 years of experience
41 sales in last 12 months
2,019 transactions all-time
Serves Colgate

About

Sara has been helping families in the Metro Milwaukee area move since 1994 and is one of the most successful Realtors in the Midwest. She has a Bachelors Degree from Wichita State University including a minor in marketing. She specializes in residential listings and sales and has developed a unique and highly effective marketing program. Her specialized Team approach provides clients true representation and excellent service. Sara, along with her husband and 2 college aged kids, enjoys many outdoor activities, including hiking, gardening and horseback riding.

Read more

Achievements

Trophy Icon
Top Listing Agent 2025
Trophy Icon
Top Negotiator 2025
Trophy Icon
Sells Homes Fast 2025

Rated 5-STAR Best in Client Service by Milwaukee Magazine, Over 175 - 5 Star Ratings on Zillow, Top 10 KW Teams in Region (Wisconsin and Minnesota), Top 1% of Agents in Wisconsin and USA Based on Number of Homes Sold

Bachelor's Degree, Wichita State University
BA, 1986 - 1991

ABR, Licensed real estate agent

Sara Dreyer's Video

Shorewest Realtors

Mike Roth

Completed Profile
6 reviews
Open 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Usually responds in 1 hr
Prime Agent Badge
PRIME AGENT
45 years of experience
217 sales in last 12 months
7,000 transactions all-time
Serves Colgate

About

With over 7,000 successful closings and 40+ years of industry expertise, the Roth Team consistently delivers results that far exceed market norms. In the past 12 months alone, we've closed over 160 transactions—compared to the industry average of fewer than four. Sellers working with us receive, on average, 99% or more of their asking price, and we do it on a reliable 21- to 60-day timeline. What truly sets us apart is our full-service approach. In a market where many sellers feel left in the dark, our dedicated team is available seven days a week to keep you informed, empowered, and in control of your sale. With customized pricing strategies, real-time updates, and detailed Weekly Activity Reports—including digital traffic, social media reach, and buyer feedback—you get complete transparency and peace of mind from listing to closing. When you're ready to sell, partner with the team that gets results—and backs it with unmatched communication, strategy, and care.

Read more

Achievements

Trophy Icon
Top Listing Broker 2025
Trophy Icon
Top Negotiator 2025
Trophy Icon
Sells Homes Fast 2025

Licensed real estate agent

Business Highlights

1031 Tax Exchange, Buyer Representative, Condominiums, Distressed Properties
Proven Track Record: 160+ homes sold last year alone—far above industry standards. Career Sales of $1.49 Billion.
Data-Driven Pricing: Strategic pricing tailored to today’s market to maximize your return.
Unmatched Communication: Get proactive updates, real-time metrics, and full availability.

First Weber Inc

Samantha Peters

Open 8:00 AM - 7:00 PM
Usually responds in 30 minutes
9 years of experience
83 transactions all-time
Serves Colgate

About

I am a full time REALTORĀ®, Broker Associate who is here to get the results you deserve. I am fun, energetic, organized, and trustworthy. I'm dedicated to making your wants and needs my priority. Whether you are buying or selling your home, I'm here to be your advocate and make every step easier for you. Communication is the most important part of the process of a smooth transaction. You can call, email, or text me when you need and I will promptly respond. With my help you can feel confident in every decision you make. In 2022 I accomplished my goal of obtaining my Broker's license. I grew up in Menomonee Falls and currently live in Richfield, WI. Before selling real estate I graduated with a degree in Psychology and Criminal Justice from Carroll University. When I am not showing homes, I am spending time with my husband and two children. My passions include singing, dancing, and volunteering within the community.

Read more

Achievements

2019 Bronze Award, 2020 Bronze Award, 2021 Bronze Award, 2022 Bronze Award, 2023 Bronze Award

Bachelor's Degree, Carroll University
Psychology and Criminal Justice, 2007 - 2010

ABR, Licensed real estate agent, ASP, SFR, Pricing Strategy Advisor

Business Highlights

Relocation, New Construction, First Time Buyers, Seller Representative

We've introduced over 4,940,482 buyers and sellers to top local real estate agents in the past 15 years

  • R V

    "The service was great and the recommendation of the realtor was fantastic. The realtor was fair and honest he gave me a very reasonable selling price and follow the listing all the way through. The house sold within the first week."
    Rita V. from Tennessee / Sold a home using RealEstateAgents.com
  • A C

    "I used the website to identify potential agents in the new city I was moving too. I ultimately went with one of the recommended agents and had a very smooth home buying process."
    Alexis C. from Iowa / Bought a home using RealEstateAgents.com
  • R J

    "My realtor was very professional in every aspect of the sale. My house sold within a week. She called or texted me through out the whole process."
    Ruth J. from Ohio / Sold a home using RealEstateAgents.com
  • S M

    "We found an excellent Realtor, who guided us through the sale and did an excellent job along the way."
    Steve M. from Florida / Sold a home using RealEstateAgents.com
  • J B

    "Very professional, we had a great experience."
    Jon B. from Wisconsin / Bought a home using RealEstateAgents.com
  • S K

    "The agent you recommended was fantastic. He stayed in touch throughout the process. He kept us informed every step of the way. The sale was quick and couldn't have gone smoother. Would definitely recommend to anyone else and will definitely use in the future if needed."
    Stanley K. from Indiana / Sold a home using RealEstateAgents.com
  • J L

    "Great realtors. My home sold in five days!"
    Joe L. from Illinois / Sold a home using RealEstateAgents.com
  • B W

    "My selected agent was very thorough, professional, and attentive to my needs. He was absolutely the BEST!"
    Bonnie W. from Indiana / Sold a home using RealEstateAgents.com
  • J S

    "Had issues with the title company, which agents handled."
    John S. from Arizona / Sold a home using RealEstateAgents.com
  • J H

    "We had a very unique situation... My sister and I live in different states and the house belonged to our deceased Mother... Service was great could not have been any better..."
    Joe H. from Texas / Sold a home using RealEstateAgents.com

Sell your Colgate home with confidence

Why use RealEstateAgents.com to find a top Colgate real estate agent

RealEstateAgents.com puts you in touch with the best real estate agents in your area given your unique real estate needs.

Only Top Agents

RealEstateAgents.com’s network covers the entire country and features top closers in every market.

Expert Recommendations

Our AI-powered, machine learning-backed platform leverages millions of data points to connect you with a custom real estate agent list.

Compare Real Estate Agents

Our profiles include information to help you compare agents and find the perfect local licensed real estate agent!

Contact Us to Find a Top Agent in Colgate

+ 1 (888) 586 2349

Mon - Fri, 6 am to 6 pm PST

customer support on phone
0

We can help you move forward in your agent search