City hero
New YorkMiddle Island

Find and Compare the Best Real Estate Agents in Middle Island, NY

Tell us about your home buying or selling needs and instantly see a personalized list of agents to choose from.

Takes less than 2 mins
100% free service
No strings attached

Featured Agents in Middle Island, NY

Frank Edwards profile picture
Frank Edwards Realty,llc

Frank Edwards

1 review
View Profile
24years of experience
45sales in the last 12 months
Prime Agent Badge
PRIME AGENT
Laura Cochran profile picture
Berkshire Hathaway Homeservices

Laura Cochran

Completed Profile
8 reviews
View Profile
29years of experience
127sales in the last 12 months
2,709transactions all-time
Prime Agent Badge
PRIME AGENT
Paul Perrone profile picture
Team Perrone - Realty Connect Usa

Paul Perrone

Completed Profile
View Profile
22years of experience
63sales in the last 12 months

Compare 15 top-performing real estate agents in Middle Island, NY

Coldwell Banker American Homes

Laura Bloom

Completed Profile
1 review
Open 8:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Usually responds in 30 minutes
Prime Agent Badge
PRIME AGENT
24 years of experience
20 sales in last 12 months
400 transactions all-time
Serves Middle Island

About

There are many qualities and skills that go into being an excellent real estate professional - integrity, in-depth community and market knowledge, marketing savvy, effective negotiating skills and a high-quality professional network, all of which are hallmarks of how I work. I have also found that providing the very best service is essentially about putting my clients first. This means keeping myself accessible, being a good listener as well as a good communicator and responding quickly to your needs. I continue to improve my skills and ways of doing business - involving continuing education and technology. Let's talk - even if you're not ready to list - I can explain my designations and certifications and how they will work to your advantage! Associate Real Estate Broker ABR, AHWD, BPOR, CRS, CIREC, e-PRO, EcoBroker, GRI, Green, MRP, PSA, RENE, SRES, SRS Licensed Appraiser Assistant Residential Energy Assessor Designation Residential Construction Certified

Read more

Achievements

Trophy Icon
Top Producer 2024

Coldwell Banker Diamond Society

High School Diploma

GRI, e-PRO, ABR, AWHD, CBR, CRS, GREEN, MRP, SRES, SRS, REALTOR®, RSPS

Business Highlights

Buyer Representative, Concierge Services, Condominiums, First Time Buyers
Even if you're not planning to buy or sell a house for years, please feel free to call me if you have any questions about real estate, your house or our community.

Coach Realtors

Lisa Molinelli

33 reviews
15 years of experience
16 sales in last 12 months
Serves Middle Island

About

They say you are "lucky" when you truly love what you do, and that fits Lisa Molinelli to a "T." She enjoys searching for just the right property for a client and overcoming the hurdles that can appear during a real estate transaction. Buying or selling a home is not only one of the largest investments you will make, but it is a very personal one. Lisa prides herself on taking most of the stress out of the equation and has a team of resources ready to help her clients during every stage of the process. Her team of specialists can help clients with legal info/assistance, mortgages, real estate tax adjustments, and permit/CO concerns. When not serving clients, Lisa enjoys cooking, being a Girl Scout Leader, and being a mom. Lisa is also an active member of the North Brookhaven Chamber of Commerce and was a past Director for the Long Island Board of Realtors Central Suffolk Chapter for many years.

Read more

Achievements

Trophy Icon
Top Listing Agent 2024
Trophy Icon
Top Buyer's Agent 2024
Trophy Icon
Sells Homes Fast 2024

Multi-Million Dollar Producer, Bronze Level Producer 2020

e-PRO, Pricing Strategy Advisor

Business Highlights

Buyer Representative, Condominiums, First Time Buyers, New Homes

Fortune Realty Of L.i.

Jonathan Kaiser

Completed Profile
68 reviews
Open 24 hours
Usually responds in 5 minutes
Prime Agent Badge
PRIME AGENT
20 years of experience
25 sales in last 12 months
1,052 transactions all-time
Serves Middle Island

About

Jonathan began working at his family's Real Estate, Fortune Realty of L.I. in 2009 and has been a licensed Realtor since 2005. Jonathan believes in honesty, integrity, and transparency. Throughout his career, Jonathan has connected hundreds of homebuyers with their dream home. With his personalized approach to service, creative thinking, and strong knowledge of the real estate industry, Jonathan is always working to secure the best outcomes for his clients. He has sold hundreds of homes, and he is consistently earned a reputation for being a top Realtor who negotiates tirelessly on behalf of his clients. Jonathan is dedicated to nurturing strong relationships with his clients built on trust and reliable guidance. Rather than high-pressure sales techniques or gimmicks, Jonathan offers strategic and straightforward advice to help his clients achieve their goals. Jonathan is fully invested in the sale of your home and ready to go to work for you with high energy, passion and enthusiasm.

Read more

Achievements

Trophy Icon
Top Company Agent 2024
Trophy Icon
Top Negotiator 2024
Trophy Icon
Sells Homes Fast 2024

Top Agent in Office 2009-2023

Bachelor's Degree, University at Buffalo
Communication

Business Highlights

Concierge Services, Condominiums, Distressed Properties, Farm/Ranch
With his personalized approach to service, creative thinking, and strong knowledge of the real estate industry, Jonathan is always working to secure the best outcomes for his clients.

Realty Connect Usa L I Inc

Kevin Collins

13 years of experience
73 sales in last 12 months
Serves Middle Island

About

I love helping everyone in Real Estate. Call to chat anytime!

Read more

Achievements

Presidents elite every year !

Bachelor's Degree

REALTOR®, SRS, CBR

Business Highlights

1031 Tax Exchange, Buyer Representative, Condominiums, Distressed Properties

Coldwell Banker Reliable Real Estate

Gina Marie Bettenhauser

5 reviews
Open 24 hours
Usually responds in 15 minutes
30 years of experience
36 sales in last 12 months
Serves Middle Island

About

My top priority is to provide an unparalleled real estate experience, defined by honesty, integrity, and reliability, to every client. With over 25 years as a top REALTOR® in Shoreham and surrounding areas, I bring expert insights into both luxury and traditional markets as an Accredited Buyer Specialist, Seller Representative Specialist, and Global Luxury Certified. My deep community roots, industry accolades, and loyal referrals highlight my commitment to client success and trustworthiness. Choosing me means partnering with someone who is genuinely invested in finding your perfect real estate solution.

Read more

Achievements

Trophy Icon
Top Shoreham Agent 2024
Trophy Icon
Top Listing Agent 2024
Trophy Icon
Top Buyer's Broker 2024

Bachelor's Degree

GRI, e-PRO, ABR, CRB, CRS, REALTOR®, SRS, SFR, MRP, AWHD, RSPS, Pricing Strategy Advisor, C2EX

Business Highlights

Buyer Representative, Concierge Services, First Time Buyers, Military (relocation)
I am deeply involved in the community where I grew up, the same place I raised my children
Past President of the Long Island Board of REALTORS® (2024)

We've introduced over 4,940,482 buyers and sellers to top local real estate agents in the past 15 years

  • R V

    "The service was great and the recommendation of the realtor was fantastic. The realtor was fair and honest he gave me a very reasonable selling price and follow the listing all the way through. The house sold within the first week."
    Rita V. from Tennessee / Sold a home using RealEstateAgents.com
  • A C

    "I used the website to identify potential agents in the new city I was moving too. I ultimately went with one of the recommended agents and had a very smooth home buying process."
    Alexis C. from Iowa / Bought a home using RealEstateAgents.com
  • R J

    "My realtor was very professional in every aspect of the sale. My house sold within a week. She called or texted me through out the whole process."
    Ruth J. from Ohio / Sold a home using RealEstateAgents.com
  • S M

    "We found an excellent Realtor, who guided us through the sale and did an excellent job along the way."
    Steve M. from Florida / Sold a home using RealEstateAgents.com
  • J B

    "Very professional, we had a great experience."
    Jon B. from Wisconsin / Bought a home using RealEstateAgents.com
  • S K

    "The agent you recommended was fantastic. He stayed in touch throughout the process. He kept us informed every step of the way. The sale was quick and couldn't have gone smoother. Would definitely recommend to anyone else and will definitely use in the future if needed."
    Stanley K. from Indiana / Sold a home using RealEstateAgents.com
  • J L

    "Great realtors. My home sold in five days!"
    Joe L. from Illinois / Sold a home using RealEstateAgents.com
  • B W

    "My selected agent was very thorough, professional, and attentive to my needs. He was absolutely the BEST!"
    Bonnie W. from Indiana / Sold a home using RealEstateAgents.com
  • J S

    "Had issues with the title company, which agents handled."
    John S. from Arizona / Sold a home using RealEstateAgents.com
  • J H

    "We had a very unique situation... My sister and I live in different states and the house belonged to our deceased Mother... Service was great could not have been any better..."
    Joe H. from Texas / Sold a home using RealEstateAgents.com

Sell your Middle Island home with confidence

Why use RealEstateAgents.com to find a top Middle Island real estate agent

RealEstateAgents.com puts you in touch with the best real estate agents in your area given your unique real estate needs.

Only Top Agents

RealEstateAgents.com’s network covers the entire country and features top closers in every market.

Expert Recommendations

Our AI-powered, machine learning-backed platform leverages millions of data points to connect you with a custom real estate agent list.

Compare Real Estate Agents

Our profiles include information to help you compare agents and find the perfect local REALTOR®!

Contact Us to Find a Top Agent in Middle Island

+ 1 (888) 586 2349

Mon - Fri, 6 am to 6 pm PST

customer support on phone
We can help you move forward in your agent search

Middle Island Housing Market Report

Market Action Index

We are extensively tracking the housing market in Middle Island, NY. Here are the strongest factors contributing to this score:

The median prices are rising year over year
Fewer sellers are listing their homes compared to last year
100
seller's market
Buyer's Market
0102030405060708090100
Seller's Market
Real Time Market Profile

Median List Price

$599K

Per Square Foot

$299

Days on Market

35

Total Listings

34

Market Action Index

100

Median List Price

Thu, Dec 4, 2025

Median List Price
1 Year

We can help you move forward in your agent search