City hero
New YorkMayville

Find and Compare the Best Real Estate Agents in Mayville, NY

Tell us about your home buying or selling needs and instantly see a personalized list of agents to choose from.

Takes less than 2 mins
100% free service
No strings attached

Featured Agents in Mayville, NY

Prime Agent Badge
PRIME AGENT
Nicole Genberg profile picture
Real Estate Advantage

Nicole Genberg

View Profile
8years of experience
92sales in the last 12 months
Heather Shea Canaley profile picture
Heather Shea Canaley Era Team Vp Real Estate

Heather Shea Canaley

View Profile
9years of experience
113sales in the last 12 months
115transactions all-time
Wayne Weaver profile picture
Era Team Vp Real Estate

Wayne Weaver

View Profile
12years of experience
42sales in the last 12 months

Compare 15 top-performing real estate agents in Mayville, NY

Real Estate Advantage

Richard & Julia Mc Mahon

28 reviews
Usually responds in 10 minutes
35 years of experience
69 sales in last 12 months
1,764 transactions all-time
Serves Mayville

About

Assisted 1,764 families with the purchase or sale of a home we can help you too. Are you skeptical of the typical real estate agent bios? They're like cardboard stiff, bland, and identical to every other bio out there. Instead of boasting about awards and accomplishments you're not interested in, real answers to questions. Such as . Will you answer my calls, text and emails? Yes. Without question. We get dozens of calls, texts and emails daily, we will respond. If we cant when you're trying to communicate we reply as quickly as possible. You'll get one of us on the first contact not an assistant. You've all met Realtors who tell you what you want to hear to get your business. Were honest and candid, our goal is to help you achieve a positive outcome. We are approachable and friendly. If you need a quick real estate source, a dose of honesty, you're in the right place. Loyalty to family, clients, and friends is one of our core values. Please read our Zillow Reviews.

Read more

Achievements

Trophy Icon
Top Luxury Buyer's Agent 2025
Trophy Icon
Top Luxury Listing Agent 2025
Trophy Icon
Top Sales Producer 2025

Awared Twice Realtor of the Year and Once Associate Realtor of the Year

Bachelor's Degree, Plymouth State University
Business/Marketing

Richard & Julia Mc Mahon's Video

Propertymatch Usa

Tiffany Borst

4 reviews
Open 24 hours
Usually responds in 5 minutes
8 years of experience
40 sales in last 12 months
200 transactions all-time
Serves Mayville

About

Growing up in Bemus Point and spending summers in Chautauqua Institution, I am very knowledgeable in lake properties and surrounding areas! As your professional Real Estate Broker, I focus solely on client satisfaction. I will listen to your needs and wants, to establish our goals and objectives. We will work together as a team, and you will continually be in the loop during the entire process. In this fast paced market, I believe communication is key in meeting our goals and building our relationship!

Read more

Achievements

Trophy Icon
Top Listing Broker 2025
Trophy Icon
Top Luxury Listing Agent 2025
Trophy Icon
Top Luxury Buyer's Agent 2025

Top Agent

Bachelor's Degree, University at Buffalo

Business Highlights

Buyer Representative, Luxury Properties, Seller Representative
Chautauqua Lake and surrounding area specialist

Realestate Advantage

Ginger Johnson

24 years of experience
Serves Mayville

About

Ginger Johnson is a Real Estate Agent in Mayville, NY with the brokerage Realestate Advantage. Over the last 24 years we have tracked null MLS listings by Ginger.

Read more

Achievements

Platinum

High School Diploma, JCC
Real Estate Broker

e-PRO, REALTORĀ®, CRSĀ®

Business Highlights

Condominiums, Lot/Land, Resorts, Buyer Representative

Century 21 Turner Broker

Taylor Bennett

9 years of experience
Serves Mayville

About

Taylor Bennett is a Real Estate Agent in Mayville, NY with the brokerage Century 21 Turner Broker. Over the last 9 years we have tracked null MLS listings by Taylor.

Read more

Business Highlights

Seller Representative, Short Sales

Real Estate Advantage

Richard Benedetto

Open 24 hours
41 years of experience
57 sales in last 12 months
2,500 transactions all-time
Serves Mayville

About

As a Real Estate Broker and Owner with over 40 years of experience, I've developed a deep connection to Chautauqua County, where I was born and raised. This local expertise allows me to understand the unique real estate needs of both buyers and sellers. I've had the privilege of helping hundreds of clients achieve their real estate dreams, whether it's buying their first home or selling a property for maximum value. My comprehensive services include residential sales, commercial transactions, investment opportunities, and personalized service to ensure clients make informed decisions. If you're looking to buy or sell in Chautauqua County, I'm here to help you succeed.

Read more

Achievements

Trophy Icon
Top Producer 2025
Trophy Icon
Top Listing Agent 2025
Trophy Icon
Top Buyer's Broker 2025

High School Diploma, Jamestown High School

Licensed real estate agent

Business Highlights

1031 Tax Exchange, Buyer Representative, Concierge Services, Condominiums
Born & raised in the area with intimate knowledge of the region.

We've introduced over 4,940,482 buyers and sellers to top local real estate agents in the past 15 years

  • R V

    "The service was great and the recommendation of the realtor was fantastic. The realtor was fair and honest he gave me a very reasonable selling price and follow the listing all the way through. The house sold within the first week."
    Rita V. from Tennessee / Sold a home using RealEstateAgents.com
  • A C

    "I used the website to identify potential agents in the new city I was moving too. I ultimately went with one of the recommended agents and had a very smooth home buying process."
    Alexis C. from Iowa / Bought a home using RealEstateAgents.com
  • R J

    "My realtor was very professional in every aspect of the sale. My house sold within a week. She called or texted me through out the whole process."
    Ruth J. from Ohio / Sold a home using RealEstateAgents.com
  • S M

    "We found an excellent Realtor, who guided us through the sale and did an excellent job along the way."
    Steve M. from Florida / Sold a home using RealEstateAgents.com
  • J B

    "Very professional, we had a great experience."
    Jon B. from Wisconsin / Bought a home using RealEstateAgents.com
  • S K

    "The agent you recommended was fantastic. He stayed in touch throughout the process. He kept us informed every step of the way. The sale was quick and couldn't have gone smoother. Would definitely recommend to anyone else and will definitely use in the future if needed."
    Stanley K. from Indiana / Sold a home using RealEstateAgents.com
  • J L

    "Great realtors. My home sold in five days!"
    Joe L. from Illinois / Sold a home using RealEstateAgents.com
  • B W

    "My selected agent was very thorough, professional, and attentive to my needs. He was absolutely the BEST!"
    Bonnie W. from Indiana / Sold a home using RealEstateAgents.com
  • J S

    "Had issues with the title company, which agents handled."
    John S. from Arizona / Sold a home using RealEstateAgents.com
  • J H

    "We had a very unique situation... My sister and I live in different states and the house belonged to our deceased Mother... Service was great could not have been any better..."
    Joe H. from Texas / Sold a home using RealEstateAgents.com

Sell your Mayville home with confidence

Why use RealEstateAgents.com to find a top Mayville real estate agent

RealEstateAgents.com puts you in touch with the best real estate agents in your area given your unique real estate needs.

Only Top Agents

RealEstateAgents.com’s network covers the entire country and features top closers in every market.

Expert Recommendations

Our AI-powered, machine learning-backed platform leverages millions of data points to connect you with a custom real estate agent list.

Compare Real Estate Agents

Our profiles include information to help you compare agents and find the perfect local licensed real estate agent!

Contact Us to Find a Top Agent in Mayville

+ 1 (888) 586 2349

Mon - Fri, 6 am to 6 pm PST

customer support on phone
We can help you move forward in your agent search

Mayville Housing Market Report

Market Action Index

We are extensively tracking the housing market in Mayville, NY. Here are the strongest factors contributing to this score:

The median prices are lower this year compared to last year
More sellers are listing their homes compared to last year
38
buyer's market
Buyer's Market
0102030405060708090100
Seller's Market
Real Time Market Profile

Median List Price

$499K

Per Square Foot

$216

Days on Market

117

Total Listings

14

Market Action Index

38

Median List Price

Tue, Jul 28, 2026

Median List Price
1 Year

We can help you move forward in your agent search