Find and Compare the Best Real Estate Agents in Castleton, IN

Since 2009, Peter has been helping people buy, sell, and invest in real estate. He works tirelessly for every client, never satisfied with anything less than impeccable results and their total satisfaction. With a background in entrepreneurship and an extensive sales and investing history, he has the business acumen and comprehensive understanding of the real estate market to ensure he champions his client’s needs and produces results. Peter is a dynamic and passionate person who works tirelessly to create win-win situations for all his clients. Despite his serious approach to the business, he always maintains a great attitude and sense of humor, and tries to inject some fun into everything that he does. When he is not working hard to help his clients accomplish their goals, you will find him spending time with his wife, two children, and dog Paxton, at his home in Carmel.

Real Estate Has Been My Passion for Over 21 Years I love what I do—maybe a little too much—and I treat every deal like it’s my own. Over the past 21 years, I’ve earned numerous awards as a TOP Agent, but let’s be honest: on this site, everyone is a “top agent.” What really matters is finding the right fit for you. Buying or selling a home is personal—and likely one of the biggest financial decisions you’ll ever make. So, do yourself a favor: interview at least two agents before you commit. Here’s what you should look for: 1. A full-time Realtor – You deserve someone fully dedicated to this profession. 2. Value beyond the basics – From expert staging to strategic marketing, your agent should elevate your home’s appeal. 3. A competitive spirit – You want someone who doesn’t like to lose, especially in a multiple-offer situation. 4. Your best interests at heart – Above all, your agent should be your advocate—not just another salesperson.

I have lived and worked in the indianapolis market over 35 years and have sold relestate the entire time. I am married with 4 adult children. I seem to like work better than play but enjoy traveling, bocce ball, golf and I like to watch baseball,football, soccer, and most team sports. I am into vegatable gardening and cooking. I have a passion for Italian wines and I have a small wine cellar/ closet. I have started many other small business ventures including restruarant and popcorn shop. I have developed ground, built homes and curently manange homes for rrent for owners of single family homes and condos.

Yearning to flex her entrepreneurial muscles, Kristie Smith left her corporate marketing job in 2003 and founded the Indy Homes Team. In just a few short years, Kristies focus on outstanding client service and great evidence-based outcomes built the Indy Homes Team into one of the top real estate groups in Indiana. The team continually ranks nationally among all Keller Williams agents in terms of sales volume. For the past four years, Kristie has been part of Gary Kellers private agent Mastermind group made up of just the top 200 agents in Keller Williams Realty. This group meets quarterly with Gary to sharpen their skills, learn from each other, and grow their businesses to new heights.

Susan is a former attorney turned real estate agent serving Indianapolis and the surrounding suburbs. PropertySpark has ranked Susan among the top Indiana Agents on social media several times over. She loves helping her clients enter the next chapter in life whatever that maybe. “It’s a very exciting time when you’re buying or selling a home. It’s a new beginning where anything seems possible! But it can also be stressful. I’m right by your side guiding and advising you every step of the way. My goal is to make the home buying and selling process the best experience you’ve ever had.” Before her real estate career, Susan practiced law for almost a decade in downtown Indy, and now she is one of five experienced agents on the Circle City Home Team. In 2025, her team sold $35 Million in real estate and helped 99 families. She's a native Hoosier currently residing in Zionsville with her husband Scott and their rescue pup, Henry. She enjoys Zumba, gardening and home design.